Preparing for the Annual Compensation Review

What you should know about compensation and benefits

1480
0



Once again, it’s the time of year for budget building, compensation planning, compensation reviews, and personnel reviews. While some companies do not align their fiscal year with the calendar year, most do, which makes the months from August through February particularly hectic for those of us in the compensation space.

Over the past few months and years, I’ve discussed several elements of compensation and benefits programs, but I’ve never compiled them into a ready reference for aviation managers and professionals. However, I recently developed a professional development program (PDP) course for the National Business Aviation Association (NBAA) that consolidates all the elements of typical total-rewards programs. As I contemplated the content for this month’s article, it occurred to me that using some of that material to provide a reference for my colleagues in the industry might be beneficial.

First of all, it’s important to get the terminology correct. HR and compensation professionals talk about compensation and benefits in terms of a company’s total-rewards strategy. Total rewards are defined as: “The monetary and nonmonetary return provided to employees in exchange for their time, talents, efforts, and results” (World at Work, SC. , 2021, p. 13). Total-rewards programs typically consist of five elements:

  • Compensation – Pay in exchange for work performed and consists of base and variable pay
  • Benefits – Programs through which employers provide for the health and welfare of their employees and include health insurance, retirement programs, and the like
  • Well-Being – Focused on keeping employees comfortable, happy, and healthy so that the workforce is more productive. These programs can include quality-of-life initiatives
  • Development (Careers) -Allow employees to advance their skills, knowledge, education, abilities, and contributions. These are largely career-focused, but can also encompass programs that enhance employees’ lives, e.g. graduate degrees, certification programs, etc., and
  • Recognition – Formal and informal programs that celebrate individual and group accomplishments and demonstrate to employees that their actions are noticed and valued.

Compensation is the element that we seem to discuss most often, and it’s here where we’ll spend the most time. Compensation is defined as: “pay provided by an employer to workers in exchange for services such as time, effort and talent. This includes both fixed and variable pay tied to overall contributions” (World at Work, TRM, 2021, p. 29).

Types of Compensation

The most common types of compensation are hourly wages, salaries, and bonuses. Compensation categories include:

  • Fixed Pay (Base Pay)
    • Can be either salary or an hourly rate
    • Non-discretionary – employees are paid a fixed amount regardless of results
  • Variable Pay
    • Typically, a function of employee and/or organizational performance
    • Includes short-term incentive payments, bonuses, and long-term incentive payments
    • Allows managers and HR professionals to be more creative

Base Pay and Associated Issues

The key point to remember about base-pay rates is that they typically operate within elaborate base-pay structures, which have required significant time and effort to develop. If those structures place aviation department personnel at the same compensation grades as non-aviation personnel, market-driven pressure on aviation personnel’s compensation can drive those compensation levels to the top of their respective compensation grades. In contrast, non-aviation personnel remain comfortably within their grade. This limits aviation personnel to the highest level of compensation within their grade and may keep them below the market level for their respective positions.

Base pay can be increased for a variety of reasons. The most common include:

  • Merit Increase – yearly increase given to employees based on company performance and compensation philosophy
  • Cost-of-living adjustments (COLAs) – payments made to allow employees to stay apace with the rate of inflation
    • It’s essential to recognize that the cost of living is distinct from the cost of labor. The cost of living can drive the cost of labor, but the two indices do not always correlate.
  • Equity Adjustments – adjustments made to pay grades when compression issues occur between superiors and subordinates or peers with dissimilar lengths of service
    • Compression occurs when pay ranges get too close together and/or have too much overlap.
  • General Increases a.k.a. Market-Driven Increases – occur when the organization finds itself behind the market rate for certain positions
    • Happens when compensation increases rapidly for positions with “hot jobs;”
    • Increases can sometimes result in the employee reaching the top of a pay band and rendering the company unable to raise compensation without promoting the employee or changing the pay structure; and
  • Lump-Sum Payment – used when the situation described above occurs
    • Provided instead of a percentage increase, these payments are made annually to bring an employee’s base pay into a competitive range without exceeding the upper level of an employee’s current pay band.

There are three solutions to base-pay structural limits

  1. Increase variable pay – while there may be structural limits incurred with variable pay as well, these actions are usually the easiest to accomplish.
  2. Promote the employee to the next higher grade – this is one of the reasons why job titles like senior captain exist – to overcome grade limitations on base pay; and
  3. Create a separate pay structure for the aviation department to allow for more flexibility. More and more aviation departments are resorting to this option.

Variable Pay

Variable pay comes in three basic forms: bonuses, short-term incentives (STI), and long-term incentives (LTI). STI and bonuses are often used interchangeably, but they are actually quite different.

  • Short-term incentives
    • Usually formulaic and are paid over a single-year period
    • Criteria to receive them is determined in advance and framed with direct performance measures. The different performance measures can be weighted differently, and the payouts can vary depending on the employee’s level in the organization.
  • Bonuses
    • Typically, more informal and more discretionary – still paid over a single-year period
    • Could be awarded based on a holistic view of an employee’s performance, or just because the boss likes to reward employees at the end of the year
    • Some are paid for the completion of a specific task, like hiring bonuses, referral bonuses, retention bonuses, etc.

Long-term incentives can be paid in equity or cash and typically vest over a three-to-five-year period. Equity is the usual mechanism of publicly held companies, while cash is used by privately held companies.

And that’s a quick summary! Next month, we’ll look at benefits, and then you’ll have everything you need!

SOURCEAero Crew News, November 2025
Previous articleYou Made It, And Now What? Understanding The Arrival Fallacy
Next articleCoffee & Pretzels, November 2025
Christopher Broyhill
Dr. Chris Broyhill, CAM Fellow, CCP, is the founder and CEO of AirComp Calculator™, which provides regionally adjusted business aviation compensation reports for aviation professionals and the organizations that employ them. A graduate of the U.S. Air Force Academy and the USAF Fighter Weapons School, Broyhill flew the A-10 and F-16 during more than 20 years in the USAF. His business aviation career includes chief pilot and director of aviation roles for two Fortune 100 flight departments operating under Part 91, as well as chief pilot and director of operations for a Part 135 operator. Broyhill holds a Ph.D. in aviation from Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University, is a Certified Compensation Professional (CCP) and is an NBAA Certified Aviation Manager (CAM) Fellow. Among his more than 10 books, the most recent is The Business Aviation Book: Leading Operational Excellence (2025), co-edited with Mike Nichols. Other titles include Business Aviation Leadership: From the Traits to the Trenches. Broyhill also hosts The Flight Department Show podcast. Learn more at aircompcalculator.com.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.