
Welcome back to Grey Matter, and a new year.
Building off last month’s discussion of passenger announcements (PAs)–when, where, and why –we’re going to continue with this theme for the next couple months, by considering different aspects of PAs. Now, in and of themselves, PAs really aren’t that interesting, and frankly, how could we spend several articles talking about them? Well, for those who do make PAs from the flight deck, those who will make PAs from the flight deck, and those who will only ever have to listen to PAs from the flight deck, we encourage you to stick around and find out how we can indeed spend several months talking about this ubiquitous (a fancy word for “universal”) and seemingly mundane (a fancy word for “boring”) airline-pilot task.
So here we go.
First, many companies actually have policy language about how and when to make PAs (especially for cabin crew), up to and including specific language to use under certain circumstances. Some even go into style of announcements and general items to include or avoid. For the most part though, and in lieu of some broad guidance, pilots are mostly left to their own devices when it comes to making them. There is no training for this and little if any rehearsal before a training captain on an initial flight informs the new-hire airline pilot that they will be making the next PA…
From there, some pilots avoid it like the plague, and some opt to communicate the bare minimum, while others welcome the opportunity for verbosity (a fancy word for “talks a lot”). Some pilots are snappy and to the point, a few attempt to invoke their inner Seinfeld (a pop culture reference to a 1990s stand-up comedian), and others drone on and on unnecessarily. Then there are those who act like tour guides, ones who offer technical speak and employ jargon, and occasionally those pilots who say nothing at all when they absolutely should be saying something.
In any case, there are things you should definitely avoid in a PA (which coincidentally also holds more or less true for conversation between pilots operating together on the flight deck), and these are: politics, religion, money, and outright deception
The first two of these are potentially volatile and incendiary (fancy words for “bad”), and there’s no justifiable reason for inserting your personal beliefs, however well-intentioned, into a public broadcast. And, if for no other reason not to do so, it’s essentially guaranteed that someone (and probably several someones) will complain about your message and you will either end up on a social media feed or an actual news report, and almost certainly wind up in the chief pilot’s office explaining your comments with a representative from the company’s HR department weighing your continued employment.
PAs with statements regarding money including economic drivers, ticket prices, exchange rates, company profits, investment opportunities – real or those involving ocean-front property in Arizona, etc., usually don’t go over as well as you think, and should also be avoided. Speaking of the embedded joke there (a country music reference from the 1980s), comedy is a uniquely experienced thing, and does not play as well as you think over the PA. Some pilots manage to pull it off, but for most, it just falls flat and takes up time. Additionally, using technical terms and pilot speak does not make you sound smarter, it just wastes time and induces aggro (a slang term for “aggravation”) because passengers don’t understand and don’t know whether to be concerned or indifferent (a word that describes how passengers feel about PAs in general).
Lying is also not a good idea, given anything you say may be fact-checked, and carries with it the potential for making things worse; so, just stick to the truth. However, using discretion and reasonable subtlety is not lying, and should be considered before making a potentially disquieting or upsetting PA. We’ll return to this next month when we talk about PAs in abnormal and emergency situations.
But, continuing with the routine for now, and by extension, the above caveats lead us to what PAs should be: quick, timely, succinct (a fancy word for “to the point”), and reasonably truthful. So, let’s explore this a bit further.
First, consider that nary (an old-fashioned word meaning “not a single”) a passenger flies these days without a computer in their pocket, and probably one or two more in their bag. If they’re interested, they can actively follow the flight (and many do), look up enroute and arrival weather, check the flight time as well as the arrival time (it’s right there on the seat back monitor), and just about anything else external to the flight deck. So, thinking about this, and if you’ve ever sat through a dispatcher’s briefing for a flight, what is the best briefing? One that is, by definition, brief; and two, tells you something you didn’t already know.
Thus, consider making your PAs short, but purposeful. Should you offer a quick ‘welcome aboard’, and a tidy little ‘thanks for flying with us’? Absolutely, it’s just polite and appreciative. Should you discus flying versus driving, the distance, time, price of fuel, and carbon footprints? Probably not. Should you make a quick announcement about probable significant turbulence ahead and the impending relight of the seatbelt sign? Sure… but should you do that if it’s 0200 (that’s “2:00a.m.”) over the North Atlantic with most people asleep and their lap belts fastened? Alternatively, perhaps just turn the sign on with a quick ‘Seatbelts.’, rather than a two-minute mini-lecture that wakes the whole cabin.
Not to contravene (a word meaning “disregard”) any company policy out there, but this does speak to appropriateness and timeliness—what and when is the right time to make a PA? If it’s just routine information, do you really need to make a PA at all? If so, when? What about at 0615, after an early 0550 departure, reaching cruise altitude and waxing poetic about flight time, weather, routing, and landing conditions that are over three-hours away, along with a repeat admonishment about turbulence and seatbelt warnings? Often, less is more.
Conversely, should you make an announcement after the plane has skidded to a stop, following the collapse of the nose gear as a result of your hard landing? Yes. You should. Now. And then exit the flight deck to assist the cabin crew and look the shell-shocked passengers in the eyes and provide for their reassurance and comfort as you help them exit the plane. (Has this actually happened where the pilots sat quietly in the flight deck saying nothing and waiting for Crash-Fire-Rescue units to show up? Yes. More than once.)
Although we discussed this last month, what is it that passengers really need or want to know anyway? Typically that the pilots acknowledge and appreciate them for flying on our airline, and that we’re going to get them to their destination as safely and quickly as possible – in that order btw (a common internet and text message abbreviation for “by the way”). Often everything else just sounds like the teacher from the Charlie Brown TV specials – “wah wah, wha wha wha whaa…” (Look this up if necessary. I really can’t footnote this one).
Also, keep in mind that each time you make a PA, you’re probably interrupting passengers’ entertainment or waking them from a nice little travel nap. Is it important to announce that you’re flying over the Grand Canyon or the Great Lakes? Probably not. Yes, one passenger may love it – but 212 will more than likely not care, and 30 more will be a little miffed that you disturbed them.
Moreover, the cabin crew has their own set of announcements as well – which often duplicate many of the things you have said or will say. Especially on international flights, where everything the flight deck and the cabin crew say is repeated each time in the destination language. For these flights then, keep it short and basic – and remember that whatever you say, a language speaker from the cabin crew will have to repeat what you’ve just said in another language. What this means for passengers is a 200% increase in PAs! Do you really think they’re listening – in any language?
When we do our jobs well in the flight deck, getting passengers safely and efficiently from point A to point B, they’re generally pretty happy. When things start to go sideways and we endeavor to let them know in a concise, non-threatening way what’s happening, and commit to keeping them informed of what’s going on, they’re still generally pretty happy. Are many of our PAs made as a matter of corporate indemnity from litigiously oriented customers (a fancy way of saying “passengers who want to sue the airline”)? Yes. Can we still make them quick, timely, succinct, and reasonably truthful? Absolutely.
And with this, we’ll end here for the month. Next month we’ll examine making PAs in abnormal and emergency situations.
In closing though, it’s interesting that as often as airline pilots find themselves in the back of a plane—deadheading, commuting, or traveling for leisure—they hear all manner of announcements, promptly ignoring them, then complaining, scoffing, and snorting about them later. Now, I’ve just written an entire tongue-in-cheek (a phrase that means “subtle mockery”) article about it, which I hope will prompt many to reflect on this from the passengers’ perspective before making their next one from the flight deck. But alas . . .




































































