The Great Airline Pilot Retirement Debate, Part 2

Who supports an increase in the age?

1726
0



Welcome to part two of Grey Matter’s look into the airline pilot retirement age debate, and who supports extending or even eliminating it.

We ended last month with the discussion of a shortfall in pilot pay and benefits, as opposed to an actual shortage of pilots, which lead to an initial scarcity of available pilots in the uptick to the early-2010s airline hiring. However, this crunch was primarily felt at regional carriers and non-airline operators. As new contracts were negotiated and implemented by airline pilot and management groups resulting in increased pay and benefits, guess what? People started training to become airline pilots again. In fact, currently, there are more pilots in training than there were a decade ago. Plus, the number of commercial and airline transport pilot certificates being awarded annually are more than sufficient to cover continued senior-pilot retirements at age 65.

Now in 2025, less than 20 years after the last retirement age change—remember, it took 47 years, 9/11, and various airline bankruptcies to change it from 60 to 65—what is the impetus to change now, and who wants it?

Well, first up is Congressman Troy Nehls (R-TX-22) who in 2022 submitted language for the FAA Reauthorization Bill (the periodically renewable law providing operational priorities and budgeting for the Administration), advocating for an increase in the airline pilot retirement age to 67. (At some point there was some discussion about 68 minus one day, but this is moot because the age extension was deleted from the bill before being passed by Congress in 2023 anyway.) Representative Nehls has no background in aviation, but he does have a brother who is a Delta Air Lines pilot nearing retirement. Coincidence? You be the judge.

Although the International Air Transport Association (IATA – the global version of Airlines for America, or A4A, which we’ll talk about next month), has stated it supports a retirement-age increase, but this is based on whether the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO – which we’ll also talk about next month) adjusts its position on the subject. IATA‘s stance is likely derived from many of its international members having a limited professional-pilot training pipeline, as well as the inability to expand operations or easily replace retiring pilots. 

Next up are the U.S. regional airlines, represented by the Regional Airline Association (RAA) which, in opposition to A4A, strongly supports an age extension. It is unclear why, as most pilots in this sector typically move to better paying jobs at larger national, mainline, and all-cargo carriers well before they approach age 65. Therefore, extending the retirement age really wouldn’t help the regionals significantly, except perhaps for a few senior captains who decline to move on and second-career pilots—individuals who decide later in life (after leaving or retiring from another job or profession) to train to become airline pilots. Since these individuals are typically older and not necessarily in a position or interested in pursuing a large carrier or career at a mainline, some regional carriers might marginally benefit by keeping these pilots on for a couple of additional years. Yet these examples are few and far-between, and inconsistent with the realities of the broader industry.

Then we get to groups such as Pilots for Raising the Age and Let Experienced Pilots Fly, Inc., consisting of a vocal minority of mostly near-retirement or recently retired airline pilots who would like to continue their airline careers to age 67, or advocate simply eliminating a retirement age altogether. On the surface, these groups suggest that two additional years help solve the pilot shortage (it doesn’t and there’s not one); and that they’re indispensable to mentoring the next generation of airline pilots (but you don’t have to be 65 to be a mentor). 

As an airline pilot and someone who knows a few of the members and supporters of these groups, allow me a moment to unpack this seemingly reasonable desire to continue working beyond age 65. While many pilots are completely fit and able to carry on in the profession and genuinely want to do so for all the right reasons, there are individuals who do not want to continue flying full-time at all; they want to continue receiving the pay and benefits associated with the job. There are those who want to find a reason, which isn’t terribly hard to do, to go out on long-term disability and simply get paid for two more (or however many more additional) years but not actually fly the line. Several have openly conveyed that this is what they’re “owed” after the way the industry treated them during the “lost decade.” Ultimately, this does no one any good except them.

As a bit of a side note on long-term disability (LTD), it’s absolutely an essential lifeline for individuals truly unable to work for an extended period. But do you know where this money comes from to pay those in need of it? Largely, it comes from their fellow employees. While the airline itself may set up the plan and provide contributions to the trust, very often it’s the employee group that funds the premiums from monies directly deducted from their monthly paychecks.

So, this is where we are for supporters of a retirement-age extension. Next month, we’ll take a look at who opposes an age extension. But as we’ll see, it’s all a bit fluid, with certain groups hedging their bets, others weighing what’s best for them or their organization, and certainly all following the money trail.

Final thought for the month and as a thought exercise—think of all those in training or who will enter pilot training based on the current projected airline pilot retirement rates, and their opportunities for a lucrative and rewarding airline career. What happens to those individuals if the retirement age is increased or eliminated? Is there room for them anymore? Is access to an airline career delayed or completely derailed?

As with so many things in this industry, it is indeed a matter of timing.

Come back next month for the final installment in this thought-provoking topic.

SOURCEAero Crew News, September 2025
Previous articleProfessionalism in All Stages
Next articleHow Did I Do as Nostradamus?
Richard Swindell
Richard Swindell left active-duty military service and transitioned to the airline industry where he flies and works as a line check airman for a major airline. Richard Swindell is part owner of VATH Publishing and is co-author of The Airline Transition Manual. He holds CFI, CFII and MEI certificates along with an ATP with type ratings in the Canadair CL-65, Boeing 737, 757, 767 and Airbus 320. For over a decade Captain Swindell volunteered extensively with the Air Line Pilots Association (ALPA), serving in multiple capacities including the national Professional Development Group Chairman, working to advance membership benefits, provide aviation educational outreach, assist veterans transitioning to airline flying, delivering union leadership training, and assisting with the furloughed pilot support network. On his days off from flying, Dr. Swindell has spent many years teaching in the Department of Aviation Technology at Indiana State University, as well as the College of Aeronautics at Embry-Riddle Worldwide. He currently runs an aviation safety consulting company and guest lectures in areas such as leadership in volunteer organizations, the labor-management relationship, safety management systems in aviation, and the air transportation industry.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.