This TAF Is Garbage!

1432
0



Photo credit: Laura Laster

Editor’s Note: This month, the regular contributor for our weather column, Squall Lines, has written on the topic of dispatch in our new column titled, Desk One. Laura Laster, the author for this month’s Squall Lines will be the regular contributor for Desk One and Dr. Ajay Raghavendra will be back for Squall Lines. You’ll recognize some crossover this month. Each author will return to their own columns in future issues.


Sometimes I hear people complaining that the TAF is “garbage,” or slightly kindlier worded, “inaccurate.” It can be easy to look at a TAF and second guess what it is saying when METARs don’t seem to line up with what the TAF says for a given time period. On this day, I heard complaints that the TAF wasn’t accurate.

TAF KGGG 031141Z 0312/0412 18010KT P6SM VCSH OVC020

    TEMPO 0312/0316 5SM -SHRA OVC010

  FM031600 22009KT 5SM -SHRA OVC010

  FM032200 32009KT P6SM SCT020

From the same day, here are the METARs: (I have shortened them by removing the remarks.)

METAR KGGG 031653Z 22007KT 10SM BKN016 OVC020 17/13 A3015

SPECI KGGG 031629Z 21009KT 10SM BKN015 OVC060 17/13 A3014

SPECI KGGG 031618Z 21009KT 10SM BKN014 BKN027 OVC060 16/13 A3014

METAR KGGG 031553Z 21007G17KT 10SM BKN015 OVC023 16/12 A3014

METAR KGGG 031453Z 20012KT 10SM BKN017 BKN025 OVC034 14/12 A3013

METAR KGGG 031353Z 19006KT 10SM OVC017 14/11 A3012

METAR KGGG 031253Z 19007KT 10SM BKN018 OVC024 14/11 A3011

METAR KGGG 031153Z 18010KT 10SM OVC021 14/11 A3010 On this particular day, the complaints centered around the TEMPO line showing visibility dropping to 5 sm with light rain showers and overcast clouds at 1000 ft. forecasted between 12Z to 16Z. The sequence of METARs don’t show the ceiling or the visibility dropping as low as the TAF predicted.

Still, I maintain this TAF was not “garbage.” The reason is how a TEMPO is defined. From the Aviation Weather Handbook, chapter 27, it says a TEMPO:

“… is used to indicate temporary fluctuations to forecast meteorology conditions that are expected to:

  • Have a high percentage (greater than 50 percent) probability of occurrence
  • Last for one hour or less in each instance; and
  • In the aggregate, cover less than half of the period …”

Breaking down the definition, we see a TEMPO does have a high percentage of probability of occurrence, but it’s not as solid a bet as an FM (or From) group. An FM group, as defined by the Aviation Weather Handbook, does not have any probability associated with it and is used when the conditions are expected to change significantly.

Also, the TEMPO for the light rain showers associated the shower activity with lower visibility of 5 sm which makes sense given what we know about rain showers and their ability to lower visibility.

Again, a closer look shows the first line of the TAF—always an unwritten FM period—does call for rain showers but in the vicinity of the airport, as it says VCSH. There were showers in the vicinity on this day. Notice this radar shot I grabbed. I added a 5 sm and 10 sm radius circle drawn around KGGG, because “VC” or “vicinity” means the particular item is forecasted to be within 5 to 10 statute miles of the TAF airport.

In this case, there are rain showers which seem to be light intensity in the vicinity of KGGG. And those rain showers may have resulted in visibility dropping to 5 sm or at the very least below 10 sm. Reviewing the METARs again, there is a trend toward lowering ceilings as the hours passed, though it never dropped to 1000’. We also see the wind change almost exactly as predicted in the FM1600 line.

So, while parts of the TAF didn’t end up perfectly playing out in real life in this example, understanding fully the TEMPO definition helps us appreciate what meteorologists are and are not trying to say when they choose to include one in the forecast. True confession time: I will admit to once having said to a fellow pilot, “This TAF was written by monkeys!” My apologies to all monkeys and meteorologists alike.

SOURCEAero Crew News, March 2026
Previous articleAero Crew News, March 2026
Next articleCoffee & Pretzels, March 2026
Laura Laster
Laura Laster received a Bachelor of Science degree (2004) from LeTourneau University in Aeronautical Science and holds an Airline Transport Pilot certificate for multi-engine aircraft along with Commercial Pilot certificate for single-engine aircraft. She is a Gold Seal Certificated Flight Instructor for single and multi-engine aircraft and instrument. In addition, she is a certificated Aircraft Dispatcher and an Advanced Ground Instructor. She completed a Masters of Commercial Aviation degree at Delta State University in 2019. She is passionate about history and aviation and shares her research through her website, The Aviation Vault (www.theaviationvault.com). Laura is an experienced manager and educator with a variety of passions: educating pilots and dispatchers, managing direct customer and student interaction, and supervising employees. From 2012 to 2019, she served as Director of Flight Operations for LeTourneau University, overseeing all aspects of flight training to anticipate and satisfy business requirements as part of LeTourneau University's College of Aviation. Laura teaches several courses within the flight department at LeTourneau University. She also serves as the Chief Dispatch Instructor in LeTourneau University's 14 CFR Part 65 Aircraft Dispatcher certification program, developing the course content and teaching students directly. Laura previously worked in System Operations Control as part of a challenging 14 CFR Part 121 Supplemental charter operations environment at Dynamic Airways, a division of Dynamic Aviation. In her role with Dynamic Airways, she was instrumental in the certification process of a new air carrier operating MD-88 and B-767 jetliners. She is adept at System Operations Control setup, FAA ATOS compliance, FAA SAI self-audits, and in training and checking 14 CFR Part 121 air carrier dispatchers.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.